Rethinking Fare Enforcement

Over 55 new fare enforcement and policing personnel have been deployed on the transit system since last year. With that increase in transit policing, there has been a string of high profile incidents of police brutality against transit riders, including a case in October 2026 where officers tackled high school students at Finch West Station. We're calling for alternatives to fare enforcement.

Over the past year, fare enforcement and policing has been increasing on the TTC, with over 55 new Provincial Offences Officers and 10 new Special Constables hired last year and an increase in police presence at stations. 

The best case scenario under the TTC’s current approach to fare enforcement is that riders are given steep, often unaffordable fines. The worst case scenario - like what unfolded in October 2026 at Finch West station and in previous high profile incidents - is that riders are brutalized, injured, and even arrested by officers over a $3 fare. In September 2026, three undercover police officers tackled and detained two teens, arresting and charging one of them, in a case of mistaken identity.

In response, TTCriders is calling for the TTC to take a different approach to fare enforcement. 

Harms of the TTC’s current approach to fare enforcement

1. Impact on credit score and lost wages

  • TTC fines range from $235 to $425.

  • When a transit rider cannot afford to pay an expensive fine, their ticket goes to collections, which can lower their credit score. Credit scores affect peoples’ ability to secure rental housing and lines of credit. As such, not paying a $3.30 fare can have far-reaching consequences.

  • Meetings and hearings to contest tickets happen during weekdays, so people often lose a day’s wages to contest a ticket.

2. Fueling mistrust and negative feelings about the TTC

5. Discrimination against Black and Indigenous people

4. Phasing out cash discriminates against low-income residents

Alternative approaches to fare loss and enforcement

1. A return to the “Taps Over Tickets” model

  • During the peak of the pandemic (2020-23), Fare Inspectors asked riders who had not paid to either tap, pay with cash, or leave the vehicle. According to TTC data, 50% of riders paid when asked to.

  • This money goes straight to the TTC, rather than revenue collected from steep fines which goes directly to the City of Toronto.

  • TTC staff could incorporate surveys into their interactions with riders to understand why they did not initially tap or pay.

  • Other transit systems such as Boston’s MBTA offer riders the opportunity to pay before being issued a ticket.

2. Introduce customer service staff at the back of TTC streetcars

3. Expand frontline customer service staff in subway stations

  • TTC staff have reported that the presence of 130 Customer Service Agents hired in Fall 2023 “assists in deterring fare evasion.”

  • TTC staff have reported that the presence of 20 new Station Supervisors are helpful in “reducing response times to subway emergencies and act as a deterrent to fare evasion.”

4. Update the fine system

  • Currently, fines for fare evasion range between $235 and $425. Riders are given 15 days to pay their fine or indicate that they would like to contest their fine.

  • Instead of issuing steep fines, the TTC could:

    • Ask riders who did not pay for their fare to load money onto their PRESTO card or buy a block of fares to use for future trips. This approach would funnel money back into the TTC, rather than money from fines being collected by the City of Toronto. This is one option allowed by King County Metro in Washington state. 

    • Offer a written warning for first offences, in line with Boston’s MBTA fare citations.

    • Ask riders to register for the Fair Pass discount, if eligible. This is one option allowed by King County Metro in Washington state. 

    • Perform a set number of hours of community service. This is one option allowed by King County Metro in Washington state. 

    • Cap fines at the cost of an average parking ticket in Toronto.

    • Adopt a graduated fine system with fine amounts rising with subsequent offences. Other transit systems use graduated fine systems, such as Metro Transit in Minneapolis/St. Paul with fines starting at $35 USD.

    • Allow fines to be reduced if paid quickly. King County Metro reduces fines if they are paid within 30 days. 

5. Improve affordability

  • Given that a significant portion of people who do not pay their fares do so because they cannot afford to pay, the TTC should consider ways to continue to improve transit affordability.

  • For example, the TTC could:

    • Lower monthly and weekly fare caps in order to make it more realistic for people to hit the caps. Lower threshold fare capping will lower riders’ transit costs and encourage riders to pay their fares.

    • Expand eligibility for the Fair Pass program. Currently, even if a rider lives below the low income threshold, they may not qualify for the Fair Pass program. TTCriders urges the TTC and the City of Toronto to implement the final phase of Fair Pass which would expand eligibility to those whose income is at or below the Low-Income Measure after tax + 15%. 

    • Continue to freeze fares at current levels.

    • Work towards providing free public transit for all, starting with certain groups, such as youth.

Information and service gaps

1. Has the TTC’s methodology to estimate fare loss been verified by a 3rd party?

  • The estimated rate of non-payment on streetcars is highest, but riders who transfer from the subway, bus, or another streetcar may have already paid on a different mode.
    Streetcar overcrowding may also result in difficulty tapping.

  • This is also true for bus riders who may have paid at a station or onboard another mode of transit.

  • The 2023 fare evasion study estimates 94% child PRESTO card fraud based on appearance. This observation was made on the basis of whether or not a rider looked like they were 12 and under, so children who look older may be wrongly identified.

2. What evidence does the TTC have that an enforcement approach will result in revenue recovery?

3. TTC staff have reported numerous times that there are gaps in the PRESTO resale network in Scarborough and Northwest Toronto

  • The Ontario Human Rights Commission (OHRC) wrote to the TTC and Metrolinx in April 2021 outlining their concerns that the use of the PRESTO electronic fare payment
    system “may present barriers to accessing Toronto’s public transit for some Human Rights Code-protected groups.”

  • The OHRC noted that the PRESTO resale network at Shoppers Drug Marts does not provide “sufficient access to physical locations for purchasing PRESTO fares, with the most significant gaps occurring in areas where more residents are racialized or experience poverty, such as North-west Toronto and Scarborough. Physical fare sale locations are also particularly important for people who do not have access to credit cards or the internet and need to buy fares with cash. As well, needing to travel
    further distances to buy fares may present challenges for people with disabilities.”

4. Understanding why different groups of riders do not pay

  • In a survey of transit riders in 10 cities, Monash University researchers found that “up to 40% of city residents evade the fare at least once a year – but most do so in “one
    off” incidents due to payment issues like no available ticket machine, a broken farecard, or someone choosing to run for the train without reloading their fare.” In some cities, between 20-40% of residents admit to not paying fares at some point.

  • The TTC should investigate why various groups of riders do not or cannot pay.

  • Solutions will vary based on different causes of fare non-payment, such as poverty, gaps in the PRESTO network, lack of staff, or feeling entitled to free rides because of
    late or unreliable service and feeling disrespected by the TTC.

  • Partially-paid cash fares could indicate that riders are paying what they can.

Approaches from other transit systems

 

Mumbai Central Railways

Each fare is entered into a daily lottery to win a cash prize, providing an incentive for riders to pay their fare.

King County Metro

  • $40 fine, reduced to $20 if paid within 30
    days of receiving the ticket.

  • Additional options: 2 hours community service or loading money onto a fare card.

“The goal is to eliminate the chance that a
rider—especially one with very little or no
income—ends up in a cycle of debt and court
interactions.”

Boston’s MBTA

  • First offense (within a 3-year period): formal, written warning with no fine

  • First, second, or third citation: $50 USD fine

  • Fourth or subsequent citation: $100 USD fine



Links:

 

Latest posts

Toronto has spent years dealing with the consequences of underfunded public transit. Aging infrastructure, delayed repairs and subway slow zones have all placed pressure on a system that millions of Torontonians rely on. These problems cannot be fixed overnight and require sustained investment in the workers, vehicles, tracks and infrastructure that keep transit moving.

Take action

Municipal Election Dashboard
Workshops and Trainings
Stop GO Train Cuts
Pledge to Vote for Transit
Transit-only lanes now: Get buses and streetcars moving!
Give Transit the Green Light
Platform Doors for a safer, more reliable TTC!
Know Your Transit Rights
Protect Door-to-Door Wheel-Trans Service!

Connect with us